-, P., -, A. (2024). The authentic Traditions in which al-Nasa’i said but Qatadah infringed him in the big Sunan: A critical study. Alustath, 15(1), 582-627. doi: 10.34278/aujis.2024.182418
Prof. Dr. Abdulsattar Ibrahim Saleh -; Arwa Abdul Karim Mikhlif -. "The authentic Traditions in which al-Nasa’i said but Qatadah infringed him in the big Sunan: A critical study". Alustath, 15, 1, 2024, 582-627. doi: 10.34278/aujis.2024.182418
-, P., -, A. (2024). 'The authentic Traditions in which al-Nasa’i said but Qatadah infringed him in the big Sunan: A critical study', Alustath, 15(1), pp. 582-627. doi: 10.34278/aujis.2024.182418
-, P., -, A. The authentic Traditions in which al-Nasa’i said but Qatadah infringed him in the big Sunan: A critical study. Alustath, 2024; 15(1): 582-627. doi: 10.34278/aujis.2024.182418

The authentic Traditions in which al-Nasa’i said but Qatadah infringed him in the big Sunan: A critical study

Anbar university Journal for Islamic Sciences
Article 16, Volume 15, Issue 1, March 2024, Pages 582-627    PDF (8.98 M)
DOI: 10.34278/aujis.2024.182418
Authors
Prof. Dr. Abdulsattar Ibrahim Saleh -; Arwa Abdul Karim Mikhlif -
University of Anbar - College of Islamic Sciences
Abstract
       Praise be to God، Lord of the worlds، and prayers and peace be upon our prophet Muhammad and his family and companions.




Disagreement is the difference between the narrators of their sheikh in the context of attributing the Tradition or its text. This disagreement is increased and decreased according to the number of the sheikh’s students. It mostly falls in the attribution or in the text or both، some of which are effective، and some are ineffective. When weighting the friction among the imams، it must be stated that there are important evidences that weighs saying of some of them، such as the imams’ affiliation and others. This research is entitled as (The authentic Traditions in which al-Nasa’i said but Qatadah infringed him in the big Sunan: A critical study) in order to show the extent of the difference between Qatada's narration and other narrators. This research has come up with five Authentic Traditions. In the end، results are mentioned in the conclusion
Keywords
disagreement; criticism; differences; defectiveness
References

 

  • After Alquran Alkarim
  • Abi Awana, Yaqoub bin Ishaq Al-Isfaraini. (d. 316 AH). Mustakhrij Abi Eawana.ed: A group of investigators - Coordinated and directed by: A team of researchers at the College of Noble Hadith and Islamic Studies - at the Islamic University - Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. 1nd ed. 1435 AH - 2014 AD.
  • Abu Dawood, Suleiman bin Al-Ash’ath. (d. 275 AH). Sunan Abi Dawud. ed: Shuaib Al-Arnaout, and others. 1nd ed. Dar Al-Resala International, 1430 AH - 2009 AD.
  • Abu Yala al-Mawsili, Ahmed bin Ali. (d. 307 AH). Musnad Abi Yala. ed: Hussein Salim Asad, 2nd ed. Damascus: Dar Al-Mamoun for Heritage, 1410 AH - 1989 AD.
  • Al-Aini, Mahmoud bin Ahmed. (d. 855 AH). Maghani Alakhyar fi Sharh Asamay Rijal Maeani Aluathar. ed: Muhammad Hassan. 1nd ed. Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyyah, 1427 AH - 2006 AD.
  • Al-Asbahani, Abu Naeem Ahmed. (d. 430 AH). Tarikh Asabhan = Akhbar Asabhan. ed: Sayyed Kasravi. Beirut: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyyah, 1410 AH - 1990 AD.
  • Al-Asbahani, Abu Naeem Ahmed. (d. 430 AH).Hilyat Alawlia Watabaqat Alasfia. 1nd ed. Egypt - Riyadh: Al-Saada Press - Dar Al-Watan, 1394 AH - 1974 AD - 1418 AH - 1997 AD.
  • Al-Bayhaqi, Abu Bakr Ahmed bin Al-Hussein. (d. 458 AH). Alsunan Alkubraa. ed: Muhammad Abdel Qader Atta. 3nd ed. Beirut: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyya, 1424 AH - 2003 AD.
  • Al-Bayhaqi, Abu Bakr Ahmed bin Al-Hussein. (d. 458 AH). Maerifat Alsunan Waluathar. ed: Abdel Muti Amin Qalaji. 1nd ed. Damascus - Beirut: Dar Qutaiba. 1412 AH - 1991 AD.
  • Al-Bazzar, Ahmed bin Amr. (d. 292 AH). Musnad Al-Bazzar = Al-Bahr Al-Zakhar. ed: Mahfouz Rahman Zainullah, et al., 1nd ed. Medina: Library of Science and Governance, 2009 AD.
  • Al-Bazzaz, Abu Bakr Muhammad bin Abdullah bin Ibrahim bin Abdawayh Al-Baghdadi. (d. 354 AH). Kitab Alfawayid (Alghilaniati).ed: Helmy Kamel Asaad Abdel Hadi - presented to him, reviewed by him, and commented on by: Abu Ubaidah Mashhour bin Hassan Al Salman. 1nd ed. Riyadh: Dar Ibn al-Jawzi, 1417 AH - 1997 AD.
  • Al-Bukhari, Abu Abdullah Muhammad bin Ismail. (d. 256 AH). Altaarikh Alkabir. ed: Hashim Al-Nadawi and others. Hyderabad - Deccan: Ottoman Encyclopedia.
  • Al-Bukhari, Muhammad bin Ismail (d. 256 AH). Sahih Al-Bukhari = Al-Jami Al-Musnad Al-Sahih. ed: Muhammad Zuhair bin Nasser. Numbering: Muhammad Fouad Abdel Baqi, 1nd ed. Dar Touq Al-Najat, 1422 AH.
  • Al-Dar Qatni, Abu Al-Hassan Ali bin Omar bin Ahmed. (385 AH). Aleilal Alwaridat fi Alahadith Alnabawia. Verified and graduated by: Mahfouz Al-Rahman Zainallah Al-Salafi. 1nd ed. Riyadh: Dar Taiba - Dar Ibn al-Jawzi, 1405 AH - 1985 AD.
  • Al-Daraqutni, Ali bin Omar bin Ahmed bin Mahdi bin Masoud bin Al-Numan bin Dinar Al-Baghdadi. (d. 385 AH). Aliilzamat Waltatabue. Study and investigation: Sheikh Abu Abdul Rahman Muqbil bin Hadi Al-Wadaei. 2nd ed. Beirut: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyyah, 1405 AH - 1985 AD.
  • Al-Dhahabi, Muhammad bin Ahmad. (d. 748 AH). Alkashif fi Maerifat man Lah Riwayat fi Alkutub Alsita. ed: Muhammad Awama - Ahmed Al-Khatib, 1nd ed. Jeddah: Dar Al-Qibla for Islamic Culture - Quranic Sciences Foundation, 1413 AH. - 1992 AD.
  • Al-Dhahabi, Muhammad bin Ahmed. (d. 748 AH). Sayr Aelam Alnubala. ed: A group of investigators under the supervision of Sheikh Shuaib Al-Arnaout. 3nd ed. Al-Resala Foundation, 1405 AH - 1985 AD.
  • Al-Humaidi, Abdullah bin Al-Zubayr. (d. 219 AH). Musnad Al-Hamidi. ed: Hassan Salim Al-Darani. 1nd ed. Damascus: Dar Al-Saqqa, 1996AD.
  • Al-Jurjani, Abu Bakr Ahmad bin Ibrahim bin Ismail bin Al-Abbas bin Mardas Al-Ismaili (d. 371 AH). Almuejam fi Asami Shuyukh Abi Bakr Aliismaeili. ed: Ziad Muhammad Mansour. 1nd ed. Medina: Library of Science and Wisdom, 1410 AH.
  • Al-Khatib Al-Baghdadi, Abu Bakr Ahmed bin Ali bin Thabit bin Ahmed bin Mahdi. (d. 463 AH). Alfaqih Walmutafaqih. ed: Abu Abd al-Rahman Adel bin Yusuf al-Gharazi. 2nd ed. Saudi Arabia: Dar Ibn al-Jawzi, 1421 AH.
  • Al-Khatib Al-Baghdadi, Ahmed bin Ali. (d. 463 AH). Tarikh Baghdad. ed: Bashar Awad Maarouf. 1nd ed. Beirut: Dar Al-Gharb Al-Islami, 1422 AH - 2002 AD.
  • Al-Mazzi, Yusuf bin Abdul Rahman. (d. 742 AH). Tahdhib Alkamal fi Asma Alrijal. ed: Bashar Awad Maarouf, 1nd ed. Beirut: Al-Resala Foundation, 1400 AH - 1980 AD.
  • Al-Munawi, Muhammad Abdel Raouf. (d. 1031 AH). Fayd Alqadir Sharh Aljamie Alsaghir. 1nd ed. Egypt: The Great Commercial Library, 1356 AH.
  • Al-Muzani, Ismail bin Yahya bin Ismail. (d. 264 AH). Alsunan Almathurat Lilshaafieii. ed: Abdel Muti Amin Qalaji. 1nd ed. Beirut: Dar Al-Ma’rifa, 1406 AH.
  • Al-Nasai, Ahmed bin Shuaib. (d. 303 AH). Alsunan Alkubraa. ed: Abdul Ghaffar Suleiman Al-Bandari - Sayyed Kasravi Hassan. 1nd ed. Beirut: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyyah, 1411 AH - 1991 AD.
  • Al-Nasai, Ahmed bin Shuaib. (d. 303 AH). Sunan al-Nasai. ed: Sheikh Abdel Fattah Abu Ghada. 2nd ed. Aleppo: Islamic Publications Office, 1406 AH - 1986 AD.
  • Al-Nawawi, Abu Zakaria Muhyiddin Yahya. (d. 676 AH). Alminhaj Sharh Sahih Muslim, 2nd ed. Beirut: Arab Heritage Revival House, 1392 AH.
  • Al-Nawawi, Abu Zakaria Muhyiddin Yahya. (d. 676 AH).Tahdhib Alasma Wallughat. Beirut: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyyah.
  • Al-Sanani, Abdul Razzaq bin Hammam. (d. 211 AH). Almusanaf. ed: Habib al-Rahman al-Azami, 2nd ed. India: Scientific Council, 1403 AH.
  • Al-Sanani, Muhammad bin Ismail. (d. 1182 AH). Al-Tanwir Sharh Al-Jami Al-Saghir. ed: Muhammad Ishaq Muhammad. 1nd ed. Riyadh: Dar Al Salam Library, 1432 AH - 2011 AD.
  • Al-Shashi, Al-Haytham bin Kulayb bin Surayj bin Maqil Al-Bunkathi. (d. 335 AH). Almusnad Lilshaashi. ed: Mahfouz Rahman Zainullah. Medina: Library of Science and Wisdom.
  • Al-Suyuti, Abdul Rahman bin Abi Bakr. (d. 911 AH). Jame Aljawamie Almaeruf = Aljamie Alkabir. ed: Mukhtar Ibrahim Al-Haij and others. 2nd ed. Cairo: Al-Azhar Al-Sharif, 1426 AH - 2005 AD.
  • Al-Tabarani, Suleiman bin Ahmed bin Ayoub Abu Al-Qasim. (d. 360 AH). Almuejam Alkabir. ed: Hamdi Abdel Majeed Al-Salafi. 2nd ed. Cairo: Ibn Taymiyyah Library, 2006 AD.
  • Al-Tabarani, Suleiman bin Ahmed. (d. 360 AH). Almuejam Alawsat. ed: Tariq bin Awad - Abdul Mohsen bin Ibrahim Al-Husseini. Cairo: Dar Al Haramain.
  • Al-Tabarani, Suleiman bin Ahmed. (d. 360 AH). Musnad al-Shamīn. ed: Hamdi bin Abdul Majeed. 1nd ed. Beirut: Al-Resala Foundation, 1405 – 1984AD.
  • Al-Tabari, Muhammad bin Jarir bin Yazid bin Kathir bin Ghalib Al-Amli. (d. 310 AH). Tahdhib Alathar Watafsil Althaabit ean Rasul Allah min Alakhbar - (Msnad Eumar Radi Allah Eanhu). ed: Mahmoud Muhammad Shaker. Cairo: Al Madani Press.
  • Al-Tahawi, Ahmed bin Muhammad (d. 321 AH). Sharh Maeani Alathar. Verified and presented by: Muhammad Zuhri al-Najjar - Muhammad Sayyid Jad al-Haqq, reviewed and numbered by his books, chapters, and hadiths: Dr. Youssef Abd al-Rahman al-Marashli. 1nd ed. 1414 AH - 1994 AD.
  • Al-Tahawi, Ahmed bin Muhammad bin Salama. (d. 321 AH). Sharah Mushkil Alathar. ed: Sheikh Shuaib Al-Arnaout. 1nd ed. Al-Resala Foundation, 1415 AH - 1994 AD.
  • Al-Tayalisi, Abu Dawud Suleiman bin Dawud. (d. 204 AH). Musnad of Abu Dawud al-Tayalisi. ed: Muhammad bin Abdul Mohsen Al Turki, 1nd ed. Egypt: Dar Hajar, 1419 AH - 1999 AD.
  • Al-Uqaili, Muhammad bin Amr. (d. 322 AH). Aldueafa Alkabir. ed: Abdel Muti Amin Qalaji. 1nd ed. Beirut: Dar Al-Maktabah Al-Ilmiyyah, 1404 AH - 1984 AD.
  • Badr al-Din al-Aini, Mahmoud bin Ahmed bin Musa bin Ahmed bin Hussein al-Hanafi. (d. 855 AH). Nukhab Alafkar fi Tanqih Mabani Alakhbar fi Sharh Maeani Alathar. 1nd ed. Qatar: Ministry of Endowments and Islamic Affairs, 1429 AH - 2008 AD.
  • Bin Bishran, Abdul Malik bin Muhammad bin Abdullah bin Bishran bin Muhammad. (d. 430 AH). Dabt Nasih: Abu Abd al-Rahman Adel bin Yusuf al-Azazi.
  • Bin Nasr, Muhammad Abdel Hamid bin Hamid bin Nasr. (d. 249 AH). Almuntakhab min Musnad Eabd bin Humayd. ed: Sobhi Al-Badri Al-Samarrai - Mahmoud Muhammad Khalil Al-Saidi. 1nd ed. Cairo: Sunna Library, 1408 AH - 1988 AD.
  • Ibn Abdul-Barr. Youssef bin Abdullah. (d. 463 AH). Altamhid Lima fi Almuataa. ed: Mustafa Ahmed Al-Alawi. Morocco: Ministry of All Endowments and Islamic Affairs, 1387 AH.
  • Ibn Abi Hatem, Abd al-Rahman bin Muhammad bin Idris al-Razi. (327 AH). Marasil. ed: Shukrullah Nimatullah Qawjani. 1nd ed. Beirut: Foundation, 1397 AH.
  • Ibn Abi Hatem, Abdul Rahman bin Muhammad. (d. 327 AH). Aljurh Waltaedil. 1nd ed. India - Beirut: The Ottoman Encyclopedia - Dar for the Revival of Arab Heritage, 1271 AH - 1952 AD.
  • Ibn Abi Shaybah, Abu Bakr Abdullah. (d. 235 AH). Almusanaf. ed: Kamal Youssef Al-Hout. 1nd ed. Riyadh: Al-Rushd Library, 1409 AH.
  • Ibn Adi, Abu Ahmed Al-Jurjani. (d. 365 AH). Alkamil fi Dueafa ed: Adel Ahmed Abdel Mawjoud-Ali Muhammad Moawad. 1nd ed. Beirut: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyyah, 1418 AH - 1997 AD.
  • Ibn Al-Atheer, Ali bin Abi Al-Karam Muhammad bin Muhammad bin Abdul Karim bin Abdul Wahed Al-Shaybani Al-Jazari. (d. 630 AH). Asad Alghabat fi Maerifat Alsahaba. ed: Ali Muhammad Moawad - Adel Ahmed Abdel Mawjoud. 1nd ed. Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyyah: 1415 AH - 1994 AD.
  • Ibn Al-Atheer, Al-Mubarak bin Muhammad (d. 606 AH). Alnihayat fi Gharayb Alhadith Walathar. ed: Taher Ahmed - Mahmoud Al-Tanahi. Beirut: Scientific Library, 1399 AH - 1979 AD.
  • Ibn Al-Baya’, Al-Hakim Muhammad bin Abdullah bin Muhammad. (d. 405 AH). Maerifat Eulum Alhadith. ed: Mr. Moazzam Hussein. 2nd ed. Beirut: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyya, 1397 AH - 1977 AD.
  • Ibn al-Jaroud, Abdullah bin Ali. (d. 307 AH). Almuntaqaa min Alsunan Almusnada. ed: Abdullah Omar Al-Baroudi. 1nd ed. Beirut: Al-Kitab Cultural Foundation, 1408 AH - 1988 AD.
  • Ibn al-Mundhir, Abu Bakr Muhammad bin Ibrahim bin al-Mundhir al-Naysaburi. (d. 319 AH). Alawsat fi Alsunan Waliijmae Walaikhtilaf. ed: Abu Hammad Saghir Ahmed bin Muhammad Hanif. 1nd ed. Riyadh: Dar Taiba, 1405 AH - 1985 AD.
  • Ibn Hajar Al-Asqalani, Ahmed bin Ali (d. 852 AH). Fatah Albari Sharh Sahih Albukharii.Numbering: Muhammad Fouad Abdel Baqi. Comment: Abdul Aziz bin Abdullah bin Baz. Beirut: Dar Al-Ma’rifa, 1379 AH-1960 AD.
  • Ibn Hajar Al-Asqalani, Ahmed bin Ali bin Muhammad bin Ahmed. (d. 852 AH). Aliisabat fi Tamyiz Alsahaba. ed: Adel Ahmed Abdel Mawjoud - Ali Muhammad Moawad. 1nd ed. Beirut: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyyah, 1415 AH.
  • Ibn Hajar Al-Asqalani, Ahmed bin Ali. (d. 852 AH). Tahdhib Altahdhib. 1nd ed. India: Department of Encyclopedia Press, 1326 AH.
  • Ibn Hajar Al-Asqalani, Ahmed bin Ali. (d. 852 AH). Tahdhib Altahdhib.ed: Muhammad Awama, 1nd ed. Syria: Dar Al-Rashid, 1406 - 1986 AD.
  • Ibn Hanbal, Abu Abdullah Ahmad bin Muhammad bin Hanbal bin Hilal, (d. 241 AH), Musnad Ahmad bin Hanbal, ed: Shuaib Al-Ara’ut - Adel Murshid, under the supervision of Dr. Abdullah Abdul Mohsen Al-Turki Al-Sayyid Abu Al-Maati Al-Nouri. 1nd ed. Al-Resala Foundation, 1421 AH - 2001 AD.
  • Ibn Hanbal, Ahmed bin Muhammad bin Hanbal bin Hilal bin Asad Al-Shaybani. (d. 241 AH). Alashribatu. ed: Subhi Al-Samarrai.
  • Ibn Hibban, Muhammad al-Basti. (d. 354 AH). Almajruhayn min Almuhdithin Waldueafa Walmatrukin. ed: Mahmoud Ibrahim Zayed. 1nd ed. Aleppo: Dar Al-Wa’i, 1396 AH.
  • Ibn Hibban, Muhammad Al-Basti. (d. 354 AH). Sahih Abn Hibaan Bitartib Abn Balban.ed: Shuaib Al-Arnaout. 1nd ed. Beirut: Al-Resala Foundation, 1408 AH - 1988 AD.
  • Ibn Khuzaymah, Muhammad bin Ishaq. (d. 311 AH). Sahih Ibn Khuzaymah. ed: Muhammad Mustafa Al-Azami. Beirut: Islamic Office.
  • Ibn Main, Abu Zakaria Yahya. (d. 232 AH). Tarikh Abn Mueayan - Riwayat Aldaarmii. ed: Ahmed Mohamed Nour. Damascus: Dar Al-Mamoun for Heritage.
  • Ibn Main, Abu Zakaria Yahya. (d. 232 AH). Tarikh abn Mueayan. ed: Ahmed Mohamed Nour. 1nd ed. Mecca: Center for Scientific Research and Revival of Islamic Heritage, 1399 - 1979 AD.
  • Ibn Main, Abu Zakaria Yahya. (d. 232 AH).Tarikh Abn Mueayan - Riwayat Abn Mihriz. ed: Muhammad Kamel Al-Qassar. 1nd ed. Damascus: Arabic Language Academy, 1405 AH - 1985 AD.
  • Ibn Majah, Abu Abdullah Muhammad bin Yazid Al-Qazwini. (d. 273 AH). Sunan Ibn Majah. ed: Shuaib Al-Arnaout and others. 1nd ed. Dar Al-Resala International, 1430 AH - 2009 AD.
  • Ibn Mandah, Muhammad bin Ishaq bin Muhammad bin Yahya Al-Abdi. (d. 395 AH). Aliiman Liabn Mandah. ed: D. Ali bin Muhammad bin Nasser Al-Faqihi. 2nd ed. Beirut: Al-Resala Foundation, 1406 AH.
  • Ibn Rahawayh, Ishaq bin Ibrahim bin Mukhlid bin Ibrahim Al-Hanzali Al-Maruzi. (d. 238 AH). Musnad Ishaq Ibn Rahawayh. ed: Abdul Ghafour bin Abdul Haq Al Balushi. 1nd ed. Medina: Al-Iman Library, 1412 AH - 1991 AD.
  • Ibn Rajab al-Hanbali, Zain al-Din Abd al-Rahman bin Ahmad bin Rajab bin al-Hasan, (d. 795 AH), Fath al-Bari Sharh Sahih al-Bukhari, ed. A Collection of Researchers. 1nd ed, Al-Ghurabaa Archaeological Library - The Prophet’s City.
  • Ibn Saad, Abu Abdullah Muhammad bin Saad bin Muni’ Al-Hashimi, with loyalty. (d. 230 AH). Altabaqat Alkubraa. ed: Muhammad Abdel Qader Atta. 1nd ed. Beirut: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyyah, 1410 AH - 1990 AD.

Muslim, Muslim bin Al-Hajjaj Al-Naysaburi. (d. 261 AH). Sahih Muslim = Almusnad Alsahih. ed: Muhammad Fouad Abdel Baqi. Beirut: Arab Heritage Revival House

Statistics
Article View: 217
PDF Download: 18


Journal Management System. Powered by ejournalplus.com